Supreme Court dismisses Gujarat government:Does your CM know nothing? Justice Shah’s question to Adv. Chief Secretary



Join Our Whatsapp Group
Join Now
  • Condemned the order to form a committee of scrutiny to assist Koro
  • The committee of scrutiny is an attempt to delay aid: Justice
  • It is not right to wait for those who are right because of false claims: Justice Nagaratna                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                The Supreme Court on Monday slammed the Gujarat government for providing Rs 50,000 assistance to the families of those killed in the corona. The Gujarat government had earlier notified the formation of a scrutiny committee to examine the aid applications.

    During a hearing on the issue on November 18, the apex court had criticized the state government, saying the decision was against the court’s order. Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the government in the court during the hearing on Monday, said the state government’s resolution has been amended as per the court order.

    However, Additional Chief Secretary Manoj Agarwal was slammed by Supreme Court Justice MR Shah on the issue of who prepared and approved the formation of the scrutiny committee. The court said that according to the government’s own figures, at least 10,000 people have died in the state due to corona, while there are doubts about the applications for assistance.

    Justice Nagaratna said that false claims for help did not mean that those who were right had to wait. In a hearing held on November 18, the court had said that the Gujarat government had forced the families of the Kovid victims to wander for compensation.

    Warning the Chief Secretary and Health Secretary of the Gujarat government to be present on the issue, the bench said that this should not happen to those who are already suffering (due to the death of a relative from Corona).

    Supreme Court Live | Supreme Court hears scrutiny committee to probe Koro’s aid petitions Who issued the first notification (formation of scrutiny committee)? Does anyone have to take responsibility? Soli. General Tushar Mehta | I take responsibility. Justice Shah | Why do you take The concerned officer has to take. Who drafted it? (Mehta later told the court that Additional Chief Secretary Manoj Agarwal had joined the virtual hearing.) Justice Shah | Who drafted it? Who gave permission? Chief Secretary Agarwal | This draft was prepared by the department. Several officers were involved. It was later approved by the Competent Authority. Justice Shah | Who is the Competent Authority? Agarwal | Sir, competent authority is at the top level. Justice Shah | Who is that Let them know. Agarwal | Sir, he is the Chief Minister. Justice Shah | Your CM knows nothing? Mr. Secretary, what are you there for? If this is a product of your brain then you know nothing. Do you know english Do you understand our command? This is just an attempt by the bureaucracy (to delay aid). (Mehta later intervened and said there was a strong possibility that false claims could be made in the aid process.) Justice Shah later said: “We never asked you to form a Scooty committee. Modification of command is not acceptable. Will it take 1 year to get the certificate from Scooty’s committee? They will ask you to bring a certificate from the hospital. So what a hospital certificate. Will give? …. Mr. Mehta, your own statistics show that 10 thousand people have died in the state. So where is the question of doubt? Do you know english Do you understand our command? This is just an attempt by the bureaucracy (to delay aid). (Mehta later intervened and said there was a strong possibility that false claims could be made in the aid process.) Justice Shah later said: “We never asked you to form a Scooty committee. Modification of command is not acceptable. Will it take 1 year to get the certificate from Scooty’s committee? They will ask you to bring a certificate from the hospital. So what a hospital certificate. Will give? …. Mr. Mehta, your own statistics show that 10 thousand people have died in the state. So where is the question of doubt? Do you know english Do you understand our command? This is just an attempt by the bureaucracy (to delay aid). (Mehta later intervened and said there was a strong possibility that false claims could be made in the aid process.) Justice Shah later said: “We never asked you to form a Scooty committee. Modification of command is not acceptable. Will it take 1 year to get the certificate from Scooty’s committee? They will ask you to bring a certificate from the hospital. So what a hospital certificate. Will give? …. Mr. Mehta, your own statistics show that 10 thousand people have died in the state. So where is the question of doubt? Will it take 1 year to get the certificate from Scooty’s committee? They will ask you to bring a certificate from the hospital. So what a hospital certificate. Will give? …. Mr. Mehta, your own statistics show that 10 thousand people have died in the state. So where is the question of doubt? Will it take 1 year to get the certificate from Scooty’s committee? They will ask you to bring a certificate from the hospital. So what a hospital certificate. Will give? …. Mr. Mehta, your own statistics show that 10 thousand people have died in the state. So where is the question of doubt?